Best Floor Jack, Trolley Jack, Motorcycle Jack and Jack Stand Guide

What’s the best FLOOR JACK for your garage?

Arcan ALJ3T Aluminum Floor Jack - 3 Ton CapacityChoosing the best floor jack (or sometimes called trolley jack) for your home or garage can be a difficult task. There are many different types, brands, and models all with different characteristics, pros and cons. Do you need a floor jack that is light and portable, or one that is heavy duty and has a high lifting capacity? Do you need a low profile trolley jack, or one with a high lifting height? Steel or Aluminum? There are so many questions that is can make you dizzy, but don’t throw in the towel just yet because FloorJackAdvisor.com is here to help you make an informed decision and find the best floor jack for your particular needs. We hope that it’s a valuable resource in helping you make an informed decision on which model to purchase. We also have many helpful tips on how to safely use a floor jack in our Safe Lifting Guide. Also, don’t forget the jack stands…doing so COULD KILL YOU!

Don’t forget to check out our other comparison charts and buying guides too. They are full of great information to help you make informed decisions.

Jack Stand Guide | Motorcycle Jack Guide | Transmission Jack Guide

We hope that you enjoy our reviews and other great content like our Automotive Blog. It has many great articles on automotive related topic such as Tires, Tire Pressure Monitoring Systems (TPMS), and brakes.

Top 10 Passenger Vehicle Floor Jack Comparison Chart

The chart below compares the top selling passenger vehicle floor jacks. You can sort the table by clicking on the column headers. If you would like to see a more comprehensive comparison, please click here.

Note: On small screens the table is scrollable (left & right).

Brand &
Model
CapacityBodyQuick-LiftMin HeightMax HeightWeightPricePriceRatingRating
JEGS
80006
2 tonsSteelN3-1/2"19-1/4"49 lbs199.994.9
Arcan
XL2T
2 tonsSteelY2-3/4"24-0"97 lbs234.54.9
Hein-Werner
HW93642
2 tonsSteelN3-3/4"20-0"125 lbs355.154.9
Arcan
XL20
2 tonsSteelY3-1/2"18-1/2"67 lbs157.424.8
Arcan
ALJ3T
3 tonsAlumY3-3/4"18-1/8"56 lbs249.954.8
Arcan
XL35
3-1/2 tonsSteelY3-1/2"21-3/8"109 lbs139.994.7
Arcan
ALJ2T
2 tonsAlumY3-1/2"19-1/4"50 lbs217.834.6
Powerzone
380044
3 tonsAlum
Steel
N4-0"18-1/4"60 lbs149.954.5
OTC
1532
2 tonsAlumN3-1/2"18-0"43 lbs256.334.3
Blackhawk
B6350
3-1/2 tonsSteelY4-0"20-0"85 lbs149.994.2

Types of floor jacks

Floor jacks can be broken down into two primary categories; hydraulic jacks and mechanical jacks. Both types of jacks are designed in a way that allows the input force of turning a screw or moving a handle up and down to be magnified many times into a much stronger lifting force. To do this, mechanical jacks use mechanical advantage and simple machines and hydraulic jacks use hydraulic fluid, pistons, and pressure chambers. Each type of jack has its advantages and disadvantages. If you are interested in learning the details of how a floor jack magnifies input force please read our blog post titled “How Does a Floor Jack Work?“.

Mechanical jacks are the ones that typically come in a vehicle’s emergency roadside assistance kit. These jacks benefit from the fact that they are compact, fairly light in weight, and do not require any ongoing maintenance. The most common type of mechanical floor jack is the scissor jack which uses a central screw mechanism to convert rotational input force into linear lifting force. The primary disadvantage of most mechanical floor jacks is the amount of input effort and motion required to raise the jack. For example, the scissor jack requires the screw to be turned 20-30 times before the jack will lift the vehicle. This can take quite a bit of time and effort. Another disadvantage of mechanical jacks is that they typically have a small base that can cause them to be less stable than a trolley-style floor jack.

Hydraulic jacks come in two primary styles; trolley jacks and bottle jacks (or piston jack). Trolley jacks typically have four wheels (casters) that allow the jack to be easily maneuvered into place. Bottle jacks have no wheels and are typically round in shape like a bottle. In general, hydraulic jacks are far more efficient at transferring input motion into lifting force and motion. Some multi-piston hydraulic floor jacks can be moved into the fully raised position with 3-5 strokes of the input handle. These types of jacks also require significantly less input force when compared to most mechanical floor jacks. The primary disadvantage of the trolley-style hydraulic jack is its size and weight due to the levers that are used to amplify the lifting range. Bottle-style hydraulic jacks on the other hand can be small and weight less, but they sacrifice stability and lifting range in order to accomplish this.

FACTORS TO CONSIDER BEFORE BUYING A FLOOR JACK

  • LIFTING CAPACITY – The most important feature of any floor jack is how much weight can it safely lift. Hand operated hydraulic floor jacks range from 1-1/2 tons all the way up to 20 tons. It is absolutely critical that the floor jack you select can handle the lifting requirements of your job. In the case of lifting a vehicle, the general rule is that your floor jack should have a maximum lifting capacity greater than or equal to the total weight of the vehicle. Of course you are never going to lift your entire vehicle with the jack, but selecting a floor jack with a max capacity that closely matches your vehicle’s weight gives you an adequate safety margin. Keep in mind that the functional capacity of a jack is often less than its maximum rated capacity.
  • CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL – Floor jacks are made out of either steel or aluminum. If you are going to primarily use your floor jack in and around the garage, I would recommend that you purchase a jack made out of steel. If you need to move your floor jack from place to place then a lighter aluminum one is the way to go.
  • DESIGN PROFILE – Floor jack are designed with either a standard profile or a low profile. A low profile floor jack allows you to roll is under vehicles that have a low ride height such as sport cars.
  • LIFTING RANGE – Every floor jack has a different minimum height and lifting range. If you need to lift you vehicle a considerable distance off the ground, or if your lifting points are high due to large tires then consider purchasing a floor jack with a high lifting range.
  • LIFTING SPEED – The standard jack takes in between 8 to 10 strokes of the lifting bar. If you would like your floor jack to reach full high in 3-6 strokes then you should consider a jack that has dual lifting pistons or a quick lift system.

TOP REVIEWS

Best All-Around 3 Ton Floor Jack: The Powerzone 380044

Powerzone 380044 3 Ton Aluminum and Steel Garage Jack

With over 380 5-star ratings on Amazon, the Powerzone 380044 floor jack is one of the best floor jacks around. Even though it is made in China, it is extremely well made. Its unique steel and aluminum construction gives you the best of both worlds. The steel lifting arm give the strength needed to lift up to 3 tons (or 6,000 pounds) while the aluminum frame helps keep the overall weight down. This is one of the few 3 ton floor jacks weighing less than 65 pounds.


Best Aluminum 3 Ton Floor Jack: The Arcan ALJ3T

Arcan ALJ3T Aluminum Floor Jack - 3 Ton Capacity

The Arcan ALJ3T aluminum floor jack is so beautifully designed that you might call it “Garage Art”. Buy don’t be fooled by its beauty, it’s as functional as it is beautiful making it one of the best aluminum floor jacks. In fact, the Arcan ALJ3T is a beast of a floor jack. It will fit under almost any vehicle yet has a high maximum lifting height. Having thick frame sides and a reinforced lifting arm, this floor jack is designed to tackle lifting jobs up to 3 tons (6,000 pounds) without being as heavy as a steel constructed jack.


Best Steel 2 Ton Floor Jack: The Hein-Werner HW93642

Hein-Werner (OMEHW93642) 2 Ton Floor Jack

The “Made in the USA” Hein-Warner HW93642 floor jack is commonly referred to as a “real man’s” floor jack. It is constructed of solid steel with the strength to lift up to 2 tons (4,000 pounds) with ease. This is not a “quick lift” jack, but it requires very little effort to lift heavy loads. The hydraulic valve is operated using a universal joint allowing precise control. This jack should be in every “real man’s” garage.


Blackhawk B6350 Fast Lift 3.5 Ton Floor Jack

blackhawk-B6350-fast-lift-3.5-ton-floor-jackThe Blackhawk B6350 floor jack is made out of heavy duty steel and is manufactured in China by Banner (now owned by Shinn Fu America Corporation). It has the standard trolley design with fixed from wheels and rear caster style wheels.Most reviews about this jack say that it’s a decent floor jack for the money.


JEGS 80006 Professional 2-Ton Low Profile Aluminum Floor Jack

JEGS-80006-2-Ton-Low-Profile-Aluminum-Floor-JackThe JEGS 80006 floor jack design is inspired by Sprint Cup’s lightweight pit jacks.  Although it’s manufactured in China, the fit and finish is top notch. The body is made out of high quality aluminum allowing it to weigh in at only 49 pounds.


3 thoughts on “Best Floor Jack, Trolley Jack, Motorcycle Jack and Jack Stand Guide

  1. Thanks for the post! There are so many different floor jacks. Has lifting speed become an issue for anyone? It seems like the only reason to get a floor jack with dual lifting pistons is pure laziness/ convenience. I personally prefer the steel jacks, I feel that they are longer lasting.

  2. KEY FACTOR TO CONSIDER: Valve Release Smoothness. The Arcan ALJ3T (and other Arcan) jacks have smooth valve release action, whereas many other brands of floor jacks release abruptly, causing the vehicle to come crashing down, which is dangerous.

    Recommend this criterion be added as part of your evaluation under “Factors to Consider.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *